Thank You

The benefit sale for our legal expenses was an unqualified success raising over $1000. We thank everyone who stopped by on a beautiful Sunday. Soon our attorney will file in Federal Court to overturn an illegal ordinance that bans us from downtown St. Augustine. The decision here is far reaching, covering the entire Federal Districts in Alabama, Georgia & Florida.

We Might Have Cupcakes !

Click on poster and copy as a reminder

The small group of artists who have been illegally exiled from public spaces in downtown St. Augustine can only be described as a textbook example of a "grassroots"organization sometimes referred to amongst ourselves as Art In The Market but more often we are referred to by locals as Plaza Artists in reference to the Plaza de la Constitucion which can be called the nation's first (1573) public space.


We are fighting back with limited resources. Our losses in County and Circuit Courts have only reaffirmed our zeal to have the Federal Courts here recognize what Federal courts elsewhere has recognized., that visual art has full Constitutional protection and display & sale on public property is a right guaranteed.

This is an expensive battle both in time and money. The City of St.Augustine taps into it's 50 million dollar annual budget to pay outside attorneys, overtime undercover police, court time and jailers to prosecute us. We refuse to be victims and have been preparing to be plaintiffs in The Federal court against the administrators of The City of St. Augustine. Unfortunately there appears to be a "shadow government" of businessmen who instruct the city servants to use taxpayer funds to seemingly protect their own interests against what they perceive is a threat to them......that's us.....the artists. Citizens do not want this. We are certain that citizens do not want their hundreds of thousands of dollars fighting a resolute group of artists.

We are raising money to pay for the preliminary fees to get into Federal Court. The case is ready now and we need to file it. Garage sales are more successful than art sales so we are having one. If you have "rummage" to donate call 904-315-2563 or e mail plazanews@mail.com and maybe that will help us.

St. Augustine Artist Depicts Pensacola

Dean Quigley on today's front page of the Pensacola News Journal Local News

The first four of ten commissioned paintings will be on display for the visit of King Juan Carlos I and Queen Sofia of Spain next week for the city's big 450th birthday. STORY

Dean displayed this painting in the plaza on new Year's Eve. Someone asked to buy a print and Dean reluctantly quoted a price after refusing to do so twice. He was promptly arrested by the undercover police officer, handcuffed and taken to the St. Johns County Jail.

Public Be Warned !

Where 'd It Go?

We were sent the top photo recently with no reference to it's location. Previously, we published the photo circa 1923, of Henry Flagler's good friend Dr. Andrew Anderson whose benevolence gave the city of St. Augustine it's few public art sculptures such as The Ponce De Leon bronze, The American Legion flagpole base and the birdbath in the Plaza. He commissioned the lions for our bridge completed in 1927

The old photo shows a maquette of one of the giant lions that graced the western entry to the bridge. It sat on the balustrade of the front entry to his home ,Markland still there on King Street. It's interesting to note how much Dr. Anderson's pet dog has a lion like look.

The sculptor was the Italian Raffaello Romanelli whose family still casts bronzes in Florence.

So what happened to the porch lion? Is that it in the photo on top? It appears to be in a grocery store display. We don't know if it is paper mache or stone. It kind of matches the lion pedestaled on the northern end of the bridge entry. History detectives.....can you help?

If we are incorrect with any"facts" please let us know

Peter Max,Chagall et al.

Cruise ship art auctions often bank on the customer’s lack of education of art in general. Do your homework BEFORE you buy artwork. The auctioneer should not be the one providing you all the information on the piece. Research, research, research. Remember: the cruise ship does have Internet access. Potential buyers should do some on-line research before bidding. As with any marketplace, knowledge is a powerful tool. LINK

We in St.Augustine have seen the "land pirates" in some faux fine art galleries (We finance) here in town using the same tactics.

More Bare Breasts!

There were these two guys, artists Vitaly Komar and Alex Melamid. They wanted to find out something that true artists really do not want to know. The question they wanted answers to was "What do people like in a painting?". In order to be Thomas Kinkaid successful, wouldn't we pursue this? Here in touristic St.Augustine we know artists who keep pumping out the same paintings over and over again. Hey! ya gotta eat right? One artist we know considers himself a "factory", unaware that Warhol beat him to it 35 years ago. Robert Torchia wrote in his book The Lost Colony that it was the proliferation of the tourist images and the discouragement of the contemporary that prevented St. Augustine from being a "real" art center.

The dishwasher sized painting above is the result of Komar and Melamid's polls for the United States. Thirteen other countries were more or less scientifically surveyed over a period of years.

Although some minor variations existed, the majority of people worldwide preferred a painting of a realistic landscape with blue as the predominant colour. In the U.S. , green comes in a close second. Americans surveyed also wanted an historical figure portrayed in the painting .Wildlife over domestic animals and walking contemporary figures in a group are also desired.

Link here to see the results from other countries.

Does anybody know where I can get a painting of the St.Augustine lighthouse? ........................Just kidding.....................there are as many paintings of the lighthouse around here as Commissioner Jones' got turtleneck sweaters.

"Don't Go There?"...

Last week City Commissioner Errol Jones stopped by one of our artist's displays set up on the edge of the downtown district. While parked in a "No Parking" zone for over an hour he presumably wanted to debate free speech with the artist. When the artist said that our group will not be sent "to the back of the bus". This was Jones' reply

"Whoa! DO NOT GO THERE". replied Commissioner Jones who is African American.

Like it or not Commissioner, this banishment of artists from the city is a civil Rights issue. No abstraction should be required. As an African American of a certain age in a southern town we have no doubt that you have experienced deep prejudices and have seen them overcome and hopefully more progress will come. Let's be clear here.CIVIL RIGHTS covers more than black and white issues and you do not own the mantle of St. Augustine's "Civil Rights guy".

Your understanding of Artist's Rights go no further than what the city attorneys tell you. You have consistently voted against our efforts to exert our rights. It is to our dismay that your circle of understanding of our civil rights issues is so limited.

OBAMACONME

KARL

Lack of Detail, Mr.Brown

A St.Augustine Record editorial of a few days ago congratulated the city of St.Augustine for coming up with guidelines regarding the acceptance of art gifts (primarily monuments and sculpture) to the city for placement on public property.

Though some of us feel that civil government involving itself in the arts is something to be avoided , some feel that this is a good preemptive approach for future art donations. Not having read the guidelines we must rely on the Record's report.as follows:

"The new rules say that if the city is offered a donation of art in any form and decides to accept it, the city gets all rights of ownership, reproduction, maintenance, storage and even its possible sale. The city also will determine a site and a time for its location. "

Once again, there is this reference to "the city" as, to use a Bushism, the "decider". Is this the City Commission that decides? the so called Cultural Council?", the mayor's mama? Is it the City Manager who has publicly expressed his disdain for "art" ?("Art is foo-foo",actual quote)

Mr.City Attorney....your research is wanting here. The recent Frederick Hart culpture donation certainly does not give the city the donor, nor the dealer the right to reproduce another in similar or smaller versions.The artist's widow Lindy Hart can confirm this for you. There will be a number of similar castings of his sculptures as the next seventy years pass. This is the copyright of the artists estate. No artist of stature will give the reproduction rights simply because someone bought one of the editions. An artist has nothing but his output and images. You will perhaps find lesser known regional and local artists willing to agree to such a proposition but they are giving up a considerable right that should belong to the artist. You wanna pay for this, that's another story.

Since the city has permitted the copyright of the mosaic at the Visitor Information Center to remain with the artist (The Cultural Council president's spouse) perhaps you should revisit that contract.

There is planned a monument/ sculpture dedicated to the "Foot Soldiers" of the 60's Civil Rights movement here in town. It is to be installed appropriately in the Plaza where there were demonstrations and counter demonstrations The sculpture's cost is being borne by a grassroots effort in the community.No city monies are involved. If the artist Owens wishes to assign his rights, it should be to the organisation that paid for the monument. The city is insisting (if our information is correct) on something for nothing.

Take your guidelines and do some more work with respect to the artist and make it consistent.The paper's editorial said"The new art acceptance policy speaks volumes for the City Commission's support of our arts and cultural community" Yes, it does.

An example of Jacksonville's statue maintenance

A Short History of America by R.Crumb

Don't know the illustrator /cartoonist/artist R.Crumb? You are not a "baby boomer" that's for certain. Here is a treat.....he will provide the music for his 12 panel artwork entitled "A Short History of America"

WE HEAR THINGS!

A Republican Speaks

"If we approve of an inauguration event in the Plaza,might that show bias" City Commissioner Don Crichlow

Whaaaat?
"This is not public property........This is City property!" St.Augustine Police officer referring to the Plaza as he is arresting an artist.

As She Caressees Her Nightstick
"I love you anyway", City police Sargent Michaux in response to artist Scott Raimondo's rude verbal fit telling the officer to get away from him.

Not Again!!!
We don't wannabe Federal employees! Stop bringing this up over and over! City Commissioner Jones responding to citizen Ed Slavin's suggestion that St.Augustine be part of the National Seashore.

Fudge
I think that he started to use the "F" word but it came out like, "FUuuuuu" Attendee at recent Commission meeting where Commissioner Jones loses it over National Seashore suggestion. Jones then leaves the room.

Tell it to Hermes
"Selling counterfeit designer handbags in the Plaza is not illegal" Officer Barbara Clifford's response when a complaint is made.

Hey! ...I went to Catholic Boys School....what the hell have you heard?!
Do you want sodomy taught in the schools? Protester (one of two) at Inauguration Celebration in the Plaza

Apathy Kills

Public space battles across the country are heating up.Citizens are becoming aware that "behind their back",the whole philosophy of "public" is being mutated into a loss for us and a private revenue stream for the so called public servants. Fortunately, we have Federal judges who understand the spirit of our "Bill of Rights"

Events In San Antonio,Texas

01/15/09 Judge Xavier Rodriguez has recused himself from hearing the suit filed against the City of San Antonio Ordinance #1193. Judge Fred Biery has been assigned to the case. A new date for the case is pending.

07/01/08 The City of San Antonio and SAPD created the Standard Operating Procedures for Marches and Parades, and has filed to lift the Injuction granted by Judge Rodriguez! The operating procedures continue to give SAPD complete discretion over who can march and continues to charge us for our Free Speech!!

03/17/08 Judge Xavier Rodriguez Finds San Antonio's Parade Ordinance Unconstitutional in Several Respects and Grants Most of our Request for Preliminary Injunction!!

There is more to our fight for artist's first amendment rights here in the nations oldest public space than meets the eye. Too often, corporate greed, privileged access and, in some cases, outright privatization have squeezed out individual freedom of expression and political action. We must protect these fundamental rights.

Attorneys and Art

At a recent City Commission meeting, City Attorney Brown submitted a draft proposal for establishing guidelines for acceptance of public art donations. He referenced a city hall installation a few months ago of a bronze sculpture fragment from Frederick Hart's"Ex Nihlio".This was a donation to the city. It was accepted and a private party was held upon it's unveiling. It has been years since a citizen or group has donated artwork to the city (The Lions, the flagpole, The Ponce statue etc) and the city attorney felt that there should be some guidelines for acceptance. Who would not agree with this?


The United States Supreme Court has on it's docket a case out of Utah where a religious group that operates from a pyramid wants to place what it calls the Seven Aphorisms in a city park, contending that the words are lesser-known instructions that Moses received from God. In this same park the city accepted a Ten Commandments monument from the Fraternal Order of Eagles in 1971.


Now, the decision must be made,....... should we allow all faiths, creeds and philosophies access for monuments on public property? Should we remove earlier monuments that may have violated our church/state separation. I for one, resent the Confederate Monument in our Plaza. Soon (hopefully)we will have a civil rights monument offsetting the belief that slavery is a natural order.


The Supreme Court decision is important to the future of St.Augustine's possible Public Art donation guidelines. Hart's "Ex Nihilo" on the facade of Washington's National Cathedral, can be persuasively argued as a paean to biblical "Creationism". Some may now be looking for an artist to execute a bronze ape grooming himself next to the city hall koi pond,depending upon the Supreme Court decision.

POP

Shepard Fairey's poster

Burton Morris"Cup of Coffee"

The emergence of a California "street artist's" work of President -elect Obama reminds us of the power of mass media. Back in the early nineties (1991 gallon of gas $1.19) the set decorator for a new television sitcom called "Friends" hung on the set wall, a silkscreen of a coffee cup by Burton Morris. That's all he needed to have his whimsical retro pop workin demand by collectors from all over. This is holding true even more so for Shepard Fairey's iconic print of Barak Obama.

Some say that Fairey is a plagiarist "turning street art into a cheap hustle that is no different from corporate advertising"

Cliche City

Mayor Joe Boles

After the city approved the hiring of consultant Jeanne Zeidler , executive director of Virginia's Jamestown's 400th anniversary Joe Boles is quoted as saying "We don't have to reinvent the wheel, and we can hit the ground running." "Reinvent the wheel" is a popular expression used by the City Commissioners over 27 times in the year 2008 with Mayor Boles as the leader with nine usages. In over half of the mayor's use, Commissioner Erroll Jones parroted the expression by the time the meeting ended. We think that it was a nice touch for Mayor Boles to join two cliche's together with the "hit the ground running" thing.

First Draft of The Mayors New Year Speech

Found in wastecan at the Alcazar Room (CityHall)

"I'm hoping that the Commission in 2008 starts thinking outside the box, and frankly will push the envelope, developing a complete paradigm shift.We have a wonderful city and the city leaders can take it to the next level and not be drinking the Kool ade of the naysayers. Let's not look back one day and say that we took the genie out of the bottle and threw him under the bus.

No , I say , instead of blue sky thinking we've got to do whatever it takes when the rubber meets the road. So let's take the lipstick off the pig and be careful not to screw the pooch. GO GATORS!"

City Manager Bill Harriss (left) and city commissioner Donald Crichlow (right)share a round of golf with two downtown businessmen/ landlords.

Internal police department

memos:

From: Jeremy Masters

Sent: tuesday,December 23, 2008 12:07PM

To: Patrol

SUBJECT :PLAZA ISSUES

Just a reminder, if charges are warranted for those folks violating City ordinances in the downtown area such as Scott Raimondo & GregTravous,and others,and have been previously cited or charged , they do not get a free pass. They go directly to jail.

Thank you,

Jeremy A. Masters

Operations Commander

Mustafa...Shoot the Artist!

Halltoon's school administrators cartoon

Mike Peter's Juan Valdez cartoon

Link on pics to enlarge
Today's news has a story that the a cooperative in Columbia is to file a 20 million dollar lawsuit against Mother Goose and Grimm's Mike Peters for defaming the country's coffee product and it's growers. Recently , here in St. Augustine syndicated cartoonist Ed Hall was furloughed from his job arguably as a result of a recent editorial cartoon criticizing educational budget cuts. The St. John's County superintendant is the touchy sort who feels that St. Augustine Florida is the center of the universe. He took offense at the idea that the nation's schools are suffering tremendous budget cuts while administration is bloated and teachers must sometimes dip into their own pockets for needed supplies. Somehow self anointed cultural nabob Phil McDaniel of the Cultural Council stepped to the plate with an editorial criticizing Hall's cartoon. This is fine.....this is America........provocative discussion is healthy and should be welcome. The local school superintendent voiced his displeasure with the cartoon. Hall is now out of a job...suspended (or something like that) Look, no one said that a privately owned newspaper must practice free speech but it surely should defend it. The comments by McDaniel should carry no more weight than any other citizen but he has shown himself as a champion of the status quo...he knows where the donors to his so called" Cultural Council" are and has a knack of kowtowing to wherever their plebeian whims take them.

The artists of Art in The Market had asked McDaniel to serve as a mediator in the "street art" controversy here in town. He has not responded and frankly we didn't expect him to as we have found he has no more administrative experience in the arts than the average citizen. Ok, we will grant that sending your kids to an Arts school in Jacksonville might make a resume, but that's pretty much it for "arts experience". Oh yeah, he plays guitar and likes to surf.

McDaniel........You cost an artist his job. In your editorial you used the term"defamation". You have in the past used the words "libel" and "slander" toward those that disagree with you. Drop the defensiveness . Frankly this statement to Hall completely baffles us ,"It's ironic that you would have used your artistic skills in defamation of the very subject that is one(of) the most valued in our school district."

Come out from your county paid office on San Marco and play your guitar in the Plaza. Get the hell away from your pretentious and supercilious so called cultural mavens They are not real and you to them are an uneccessary dalliance with a token handout. "Art is Foo-Foo." City Manager William Harriss ,August 08, City Commission meeting

YOUR TAX DOLLARS AT WORK - ARTISTS GONE !

Last week the local news paper here, "The St. Augustine Record" reported that recently almost 20,000 dollars had been paid to hired counsel Michael Kahn of Melbourne to prosecute artist Suvo on a single charge of "offering for sale" artwork on St. George Street. Each side gave oral arguments of one half hour before Judge Wendy Berger. Contrary to previous Federal precedents he was found guilty and the fine of 165 dollars remained.

Mr. Kahn submitted his bill and was paid 19, 700 dollars from your tax dollars! This was for prosecution of one city code infraction. Suvo has perhaps a dozen more scheduled for trial along with seven other artists.

On New Years Eve two Art In The Market artists, Scott Raimondo and Dean Quigley were jailed for "offering for sale" artworks in the Plaza De La Constitucion. Undercover officers being paid overtime were used to solicit a price quote from each artist. These two desperate criminals were handcuffed and taken to the St. John's County jail and finally bonded out just moments before midnight, ringing in the New Year, 2009.

According to S.A.P.D. Commander Fricke, the city is "stepping up enforcement" by not only continue issuing 100 dollar citations but will now "take the artists directly to jail" before trial for "violating" ordinance 22-6. Meanwhile, the city permits musicians with tip jars and sellers of counterfeit designer purses to operate without hassle. Clearly this is directed solely at visual artists . City Manager Mr. William ("Art is Foo Foo") Harris and his landlord cronies feel that they are above the law and can use taxpayer funds to harass the artists to "protect" their interests, particularly in the case of Len Cutter who owns four art galleries surrounding the Plaza. He must feel that as an important man in this community he can dictate what takes place in "HIS" front yard, the Plaza De La Constitucion.........the nations oldest public space as stated on a sign near St. George Street.

So, as of New Year's Day 2009, after almost 450 years, you no longer have the ability or right to acquire artwork from the artist vendors of St. Augustine. Big Brother has won......................so far. The First Amendment does not exist in St. Augustine. Thank the artists for a good fight but we have drained our resources and will , fighting for our (and yours) natural rights.

This community should be ashamed, permitting this behaviour by unscrupulous city officials.